RALUMO · HotNews
Romanian Constitutional Court divided over magistrates' salary arrears
The Constitutional Court of Romania has released its grounds for the one-billion-euro dispute between the government and the High Court of Cassation. The executive's petition was rejected as inadmissible by a majority, while four judges expressed diverging opinions regarding the limits of judicial power in budgetary matters.

Tools
The Constitutional Court of Romania has published the grounds for the verdict of 7 October in which it declared inadmissible the appeal of then-Prime Minister Ilie Bolojan. As reported by the news outlet HotNews, the dispute concerned the alleged institutional conflict between the government and the High Court of Cassation and Justice regarding the payment of salary arrears to magistrates, estimated at around five billion lei, equivalent to one billion euros.
The decision to reject the appeal without examining its merits was supported by a majority of five judges: Gheorghe Stan, Cristian Deliorga, Bogdan Licu, Mihai Busuioc, and Mihaela Ciochină. According to the five judges, the Constitutional Court cannot turn into a body of review for final judicial decisions, as this would exceed its prerogatives and violate the fundamental order and the rule of law. Judge Csaba Asztalos expressed a concurring opinion, recalling the duty of loyal cooperation between powers.
The positions of the remaining members of the panel diverged. President Simina Tănăsescu and judge Dacian Dragoș drafted a separate brief arguing the existence of a constitutional conflict. In their view, imposing a budget rectification on the executive and parliament through a judicial ruling breaches the separation of powers and generates an incurable institutional impasse.
Judge Laura Scântei also expressed dissent, considering the appeal fully admissible. According to the judge, judicial independence does not entail control over the national budget nor the power to substitute for parliament, while also noting that the deferral of payments must not turn into a permanent non-execution of enforcement titles established by law.
Sources and references
HotNews ↗ · Source date