RALUMO · BBC News
Scotland, a surgeon reports avoidable deaths and calls for a criminal investigation into NHS Grampian
A surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has urged an investigation into corporate manslaughter against the healthcare board NHS Grampian. The doctor reports alleged avoidable deaths in the operating room and prolonged structural negligence, releasing confidential external expert reports on serious critical issues in liver and pancreatic surgeries.

Tools
A consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has called for the opening of a corporate manslaughter investigation regarding alleged avoidable deaths that occurred for years under the healthcare management of NHS Grampian. As reported by BBC News, Mohammed Habib, in service with the board since 2014, stated that he had reported these concerns for a decade to ministers and the police, without obtaining adequate responses. During a press conference with his lawyer Aamer Anwar, the doctor expressed his wish to clarify administrative responsibilities.
The professional released an unpublished 2022 external review conducted on 45 patients who underwent liver and pancreas surgery between 2015 and 2021. The document identified 31 total deaths, considering 19 of them avoidable due to surgical complications, including severe bleeding. In the 2017-2020 period, 30-day mortality for major liver resections reached 12% compared to an expected rate of 2.2%, highlighting overly aggressive operative strategies and planning deficiencies.
A second recent report reiterated the existence of structural problems and a shortage of specialist staff, recommending the suspension of such complex surgeries at the facility. Habib explained that he reported 20 cases to Police Scotland in 2024, without any formal charges being brought, and that he had contacted government officials and oversight bodies in vain.
The chief executive of NHS Grampian, Laura Skaife-Knight, stated that a thorough investigation has already been carried out and that any new element will be examined through the designated clinical, legal, and governance channels. A spokesperson for the Scottish Government acknowledged the whistleblower's initiative, noting the substantial support already provided to the local healthcare board.
Sources and references
BBC News ↗ · Source date